Rutgers Climate Change Warnings and Recommendations Ignored by Christie DEP

As a result of Gov. Christie’s political denial of climate change, NJ’s drinking water infrastructure will remain highly vulnerable to climate change impacts

photo from Monmouth County of the affected pipe (source: Star Ledger)

The NJ Water Supply Advisory Council met last Friday.

It remains unclear if the long overdue Water Supply Plan Update will ever be released for public review – former DEP Commissioner Mark Mauriello has called that failure “embarrassing”.

But one thing is clear:

The DEP’s Statewide Water Supply Plan will not include climate change impacts, despite stern warnings from Rutgers University and the NJ Climate Adaptation Alliance.  Rutgers professor Dan Van Abs – formerly head of DEP’s water supply planning team – briefed the WSAC on August 18 and his recommended actions were rejected.

I asked about this Van Abs briefing and specifically put that question directly to the Commission and DEP at Friday’s meeting and was told that no climate impact or adaptation work would be included in the next plan update.

That is shockingly irresponsible – just ask the people in Monmouth County – who sufffered a climate change related water emergency – about that.

It looks like the Christie Administration’s highly touted “asset management” approach to water infrastructure is seriously flawed (see also: DEP Dims The Lights on Clean Water).

This is despite the fact that, according to DEP Commissioner Martin’s testimony, Sandy had devastating impacts on NJ’s drinking water infrastructure, harming drinking water treatment at 400 plants:

But as a result of Gov. Christie’s political denial of climate change, NJ’s drinking water infrastructure will remain highly vulnerable to climate change impacts.

[This is not the first time, but a pattern of failure and denial, see:

“So none of this work is getting done,” said Bill Wolfe, a 30-year-veteran of DEP and now a harsh critic.

“And if you want to get something done, the DEP has all the tools to get something done and they’ve chosen not to use those tools for political reasons, reflecting the Governor’s priorities and Governor’s policy,” Wolfe said. “And they just don’t want to own up to that.”

To Bill Wolfe, director of the environmental group NJ PEER, “the Rutgers work shows how the FEMA maps underestimate risks.” He wants to see the new tool formally incorporated by the two agencies.

“Buildings and infrastructure like roads, water and sewer and storm water have useful lives of more than 50 years,” Wolfe said. “What we build today will see the Rutgers elevations.”

Read the full story, from our friends at the PEER DC Office:

NEW JERSEY UNPREPARED FOR CLIMATE THREATS TO WATER SUPPLIES – Absence of Planning & Regulatory Freeze Stymie Critical Water Management Steps

Posted on Sep 26, 2013  | Tags: New Jersey

Trenton — Experts see climate change having major impacts on New Jersey’s water supplies and infrastructure but the state is not paying attention, according to documents posted today by Public Employees for Environmental Responsibility (PEER). Failure to take steps in the short-term allows risks to multiply while forfeiting flexibility needed to effectively avert, mitigate or respond to coming water emergencies.

Rutgers Professor Dan Van Abs outlined effects the state should expect to see from climate change at the August 18th meeting of the state Water Supply Advisory Council, according to its minutes, including:

  • Sea level rise will cause saltwater intrusion into groundwater supplies;
  • Chemical and biological changes in water quality due to higher temperatures, more flooding and invasive species infestations; and
  • More intense storms will create more turbidity, thus increasing treatment costs.

When asked what actions are most needed, the first step he named was that the Statewide Water Supply Plan should be released. But that plan is long overdue and appears to be mired in politics. At a recent joint Senate-Assembly meeting on Hurricane Sandy recovery, former Department of Environmental Protection (DEP) Commissioner Mark Mauriello testified that:

“…we have a State Water Supply Plan that is 17 years old. It’s an embarrassment… [The] Water Supply Management Act requires that this plan be updated every five years. It hasn’t been updated since 1996. When I took over as Commissioner and had the authority to really boss people around, I had our Water Supply Division, in one year, complete a final draft update of that plan, which was being reviewed in December of ’09. Unfortunately I ran out of time due to the circumstances of the election… that plan has languished. And the word from DEP now is that they have ‘parked the plan.’ That’s a quote from the highest levels of the agency. We have to get the plan out of park.”

“Since we last had a water plan, a lot has changed besides the climate – higher demand, greater loss of wetlands, vernal pools and riparian buffers plus our infrastructure has gotten older,” stated New Jersey PEER Director Bill Wolfe, pointing out that the 1996 plan is even further out of date since it was based upon hydrological data from the 1980’s. “Without an up-to-date plan, the state will carom from one water crisis to the next, seesawing from drought to floods.”

The state’s rudderless water posture is aggravated by Christie administration polices, such as a regulatory moratorium which prevents updated water supply regulations and a “Red Tape” review designed to roll back rules related to water resource management. Even though it advises DEP, no DEP staff even attended the last Water Supply Advisory Council meeting and the current DEP Commissioner has never met with the Council.

“New Jersey water planning is adrift due to lack of executive branch leadership,” added Wolfe, noting a 2013 U.S. Government Accountability Office report calling for greater federal-state cooperation in water infrastructure planning. “New Jersey can no longer afford to pretend that climate change is a topic solely for academics without major real world consequences.”


Read the Water Supply Advisory Council minutes (pages 3-4)

See former Commissioner Mauriello’s testimony (page 24)

View requirements of state Water Supply Management Act

Examine GAO report

Look at lack of climate planning in state’s post-Sandy efforts

New Jersey PEER is a state chapter of a national alliance of state and federal agency resource professionals working to ensure environmental ethics and government accountability

Categories: Uncategorized Tags:
  1. No comments yet.
  1. May 26th, 2015 at 18:40 | #1
  2. June 6th, 2015 at 12:26 | #2
  3. June 27th, 2015 at 08:16 | #3
You must be logged in to post a comment.